Pockets of Restraint in Violent Security Forces

Why resistance to following orders occurs at individual, unit, institutional levels

Publication 23 Apr 2026

In democracies and autocracies across the world, security forces respond to protests in varying ways—some obey repressive orders, some are amenable to democratic reforms, some show restraint, and some use excessive force. Why is this? Whereas most contemporary studies focus on these differences within individual countries, Sabrina Karim looks more globally at the underlying causes for such differentiation across nations by considering sociological categories such as sex, military rank, social networks, leadership experience, gender equality, training, UN peacekeeping experience, exposure to combat, and participation in different units. In so doing, Karim outlines a broader understanding of when and why resistance to following orders occurs and illuminates its causes at the individual, unit, and institutional level.

This fellowship is made possible through philanthropic support from the Alfried Krupp von Bohlen und Halbach Foundation.

Watch the Video

Related content

Fascism’s Lingering: Regime Change and Moral Reckoning

What Theodor Adorno and his Institute for Social Research team learned about the lasting impact of Nazi ideologies on the German psyche in 1950-51.

2 Oct 2026

London Falling

Patrick Radden Keefe’s book on the seedy truths behind glamorous London

29 Sep 2026

Moveable Type and the Early Modern Imaginary

Image reproduction and the Early Modern mental universe

24 Sep 2026

The USA and Europe: Between Alliance and Shared Responsibility

Panel discussion with John R. Bolton, Norbert Röttgen, Ethan Kapstein, and Majid Sattar.

15 Sep 2026
Diese Medieninhalte sind derzeit blockiert.
Um eingebettete Videos oder Social-Media-Beiträge anzuzeigen, erlauben Sie bitte Cookies von externen Medienanbietern in Ihren Datenschutzeinstellungen.